As India announced its 15-member provisional squad for the upcoming ICC World Cup, the debate over Shardul Thakur’s all-rounder abilities has intensified. Captain Rohit Sharma emphasized the importance of batting depth, but former BCCI chief selector Krishnamachari Srikkanth questioned whether Shardul Thakur truly fits the all-rounder role for ODI cricket.
Shardul Thakur’s Role in Batting DepthÂ
Captain Rohit Sharma stressed the need for depth in both batting and bowling in modern-day cricket. He highlighted that even lower-order batsmen, including the No. 11, should be capable of contributing runs to create a competitive edge. Rohit mentioned that an extra 15-20 runs from the tail-enders could make a significant difference.
Shardul Thakur, known for his improved batting skills and ability to “make things happen” as a bowler, has often been considered an all-rounder option for India. His presence at No. 8 in the batting order adds to the desired depth, as per Rohit’s vision.
The Heated Debate
Former BCCI chief selector Krishnamachari Srikkanth, during a discussion on Star Sports, challenged the notion of Shardul Thakur being a complete all-rounder. Srikkanth questioned Thakur’s ability to deliver consistently with both bat and ball in ODI cricket, pointing out his limited number of ten-over spells and modest batting performances.
Srikkanth stated, “Everyone is saying we need a batter at No. 8…who needs a batter at No. 8? Shardul Thakur is only scoring 10 there and he doesn’t even bowl for 10 overs.”
Recalling Past Strategies
Srikkanth urged selectors to evaluate players based on their performances against top-tier teams like Australia and New Zealand, rather than looking solely at overall statistics. He emphasized that standout performances against stronger opponents should carry more weight.
To illustrate his point, Srikkanth referred to the 2011 World Cup squad’s reserves, which included spinners like R Ashwin and Piyush Chawla, a medium-pacer in Munaf Patel, and a batter in Yusuf Pathan. This historical context highlighted the importance of selecting players based on their specific roles and contributions against formidable opponents.
As India prepares for the ICC World Cup, the debate over Shardul Thakur’s suitability as an all-rounder continues to captivate cricket enthusiasts and experts alike. The final squad selection will provide clarity on whether India opts for batting depth or explores alternative bowling options.
Stay updated with all the cricketing action, follow Cricadium on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram
