Cricket, often dubbed the gentleman’s game, has witnessed its share of controversies, with players occasionally stepping beyond the spirit of the sport. One of the most recent episodes involved Indian women’s cricket captain, Harmanpreet Kaur, who broke the stumps in frustration after being declared LBW during a match against Bangladesh. Known for her aggressive style both on and off the field, her career has been marked by not only match-winning performances but also contentious incidents. From defending her teammates amidst the “Spirit of Cricket” debate to clashes with senior players like Mithali Raj and even facing personal challenges like allegations of a fake degree, Harmanpreet has been a polarizing figure in women’s cricket. Her latest outburst during a series against Bangladesh has once again brought her into the spotlight, reigniting debates about sportsmanship and leadership. This blog delves into some of the most prominent controversies surrounding the woman cricket.
Harmanpreet Kaur’s Temper Flare in Bangladesh
One of Harmanpreet Kaur’s most recent controversies occurred during India’s tour of Bangladesh, where she lost her cool after being given out LBW. Frustrated, Kaur smashed the stumps with her bat and criticized the umpires for their decisions during the post-match presentation. She went further by suggesting that India should prepare for substandard umpiring when playing in Bangladesh. The incident didn’t stop there, as during the post-match photo session, she sarcastically called for the umpires to join the team in holding the trophy. Her comments were not well-received by her Bangladesh counterpart, Nigar Sultana Joty, who deemed Kaur’s behavior disrespectful and unsporting. This controversy has reignited the conversation about the importance of keeping emotions in check on the field.
Spirit of Cricket: Harmanpreet Defends Deepti Sharma
In September 2022, Harmanpreet Kaur found herself in the middle of a global cricket controversy when she defended Deepti Sharma’s decision to run out England’s Charlie Dean in an ODI match. Dean was backing up too far, and Sharma ran her out at the non-striker’s end, which many argued was against the spirit of cricket, even though it was within the rules. Harmanpreet firmly supported Deepti, stating that her actions were lawful and fair. This incident sparked a major debate in the cricketing world, with several prominent figures criticizing the Indian skipper for not calling Dean back. However, Kaur remained unshaken, standing by her teammate and asserting that the game was played according to the rules.
Mithali Raj’s Exclusion in the 2018 Women’s T20 World Cup
Another significant controversy involving Harmanpreet Kaur was during the 2018 Women’s T20 World Cup, where she excluded veteran Mithali Raj from the playing XI in critical matches, including the semi-final. Mithali, who had been in good form with back-to-back fifties in earlier matches, was replaced by Arundhati Reddy, a fast-bowling all-rounder. The decision to drop Raj, especially in a high-stakes game, drew massive criticism. Post-tournament, Mithali publicly expressed her frustration, and her manager called Kaur “manipulative” and “immature” on social media. While the tweet was deleted, the controversy escalated, drawing attention to the internal conflicts within the Indian women’s cricket team.
Supporting Ramesh Powar Amid Mithali Raj’s Complaint
The fallout from Mithali Raj’s exclusion led to further turmoil when Raj lodged an official complaint with the BCCI, calling for coach Ramesh Powar’s removal from the team. However, Harmanpreet Kaur and Smriti Mandhana publicly supported Powar, with Kaur even stating that replacing him would force the team to start from scratch. This public backing of Powar by Kaur deepened the divide within the team and drew criticism from former cricketers like Sanjay Manjrekar. Kaur later clarified her stance in an interview, explaining her perspective on the situation and acknowledging Mithali Raj’s seniority but defending her actions as necessary for the team’s progress.
Denise Annetts Controversy: A Landmark Moment in Women’s Cricket
Denise Annetts, a former Australian cricketer who played from 1985 to 1993, made headlines when she claimed her exclusion from the national team was due to her not being a lesbian. This allegation caused significant controversy, as at the time, Australian discrimination laws only protected homosexuals, making it impossible for the Australian Anti-Discrimination Board to investigate her complaint. The then-captain, Belinda Clark, expressed her frustration publicly, further intensifying the debate. This incident highlights the complexities of gender and sexuality issues in sports, especially during a period when inclusivity was not as widely discussed as it is today.
Gujarat Giants Controversy with Deandra Dottin
Another controversy in women’s cricket involved the Gujarat Giants during the inaugural Women’s Premier League (WPL). Just before the tournament, the franchise released West Indian cricketer Deandra Dottin, citing her inability to recover from a medical condition. Dottin publicly refuted these claims, releasing a statement explaining that she had received medical clearance weeks before the tournament began. The Giants maintained that they had not received the necessary medical clearance, but the incident left many questioning the transparency of the situation. Dottin’s exclusion was further compounded by injuries to the team’s captain, Beth Mooney, which derailed their WPL campaign.
Alex Hartley and Rory Burns’ Social Media Spat
A controversial online exchange between England cricketers Rory Burns and Alex Hartley grabbed headlines in early 2021. After England’s men’s team suffered a humiliating two-day defeat to India in a Test match, Hartley, a women’s international cricketer, tweeted a light-hearted comment about the timing of the defeat coinciding with England women’s game. Burns, along with other male cricketers, took offense to the tweet, interpreting it as disrespectful to the men’s game. The Twitter spat, which drew widespread criticism, brought to light the ongoing debate about the professional relationship between male and female cricketers, and the disparities in their treatment and support systems.
Harmanpreet Kaur’s journey as a cricketer and captain has been one filled with remarkable achievements, yet marred by numerous controversies. From defending Deepti Sharma‘s controversial run-out of Charlie Dean to facing criticism over her exclusion of Mithali Raj from key matches, Kaur’s leadership decisions have often sparked heated debates. Her off-field troubles, including the demotion in Punjab Police due to a disputed degree and the recent outburst during the Bangladesh series, have further added to the spotlight on her. While her contributions to Indian cricket remain undeniable, her leadership has continually walked a fine line between defiance and controversy, leaving her legacy as both a champion and a polarizing figure in the sport.
Stay updated with all the cricketing action, follow Cricadium on WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter, Telegram, and Instagram
