Pat Cummins Criticizes ICC’s Decision to Let India Play All Matches in Dubai: ‘It Gives Them a Huge Advantage’

The Champions Trophy 2025 is in full swing, and while India has been dominating the group stage, controversy surrounds the ICC’s decision to allow India to play all their matches in Dubai instead of traveling to Pakistan, the official tournament host. Australian skipper Pat Cummins has voiced his concerns, stating that playing on the same ground throughout the tournament gives India a “huge advantage.”

India’s Matches in Dubai: A Controversial ICC Decision

Due to political tensions between India and Pakistan, the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) and the International Cricket Council (ICC) decided that India would not travel to Pakistan for the Champions Trophy. Instead, all their matches are being held at the Dubai International Cricket Stadium, raising questions about fair play and neutrality in the tournament.

Several former players, analysts, and international cricketers have expressed concerns about this decision, arguing that playing on a consistent pitch and conditions gives India an upper hand over teams who have to adjust to different venues.

Pat Cummins’ Take on India’s Advantage

During an interview with Yahoo Sports Australia, Pat Cummins openly criticized the ICC’s decision, stating:

“I think it’s good that the tournament can go on, but obviously it does give them (India) a huge advantage playing on the same ground. They already look very strong and they’ve got that obvious benefit of playing all their games there.”

Cummins’ comments reflect the growing sentiment that India’s familiarity with the conditions in Dubai gives them a competitive edge over other teams, who must travel between venues, adapt to different pitches, and manage varying weather conditions.

India’s Dominant Start in Champions Trophy 2025

Despite the controversy, India has been in top form, securing back-to-back wins in the group stage:

Match 1: India defeated Bangladesh by six wickets, with Shubman Gill scoring a century.

Match 2: India triumphed over Pakistan by six wickets, with Virat Kohli smashing a match-winning century (100 off 111 balls)* and Shreyas Iyer contributing 56 runs.

With these victories, India is currently at the top of Group A, looking like strong contenders for the semi-finals.

Does Playing on the Same Ground Really Give India an Advantage?

There is divided opinion on whether playing all matches in Dubai truly benefits India or if it is simply a result of external geopolitical factors.

Arguments in Favor of India’s Advantage:

Familiar Conditions: Playing all matches in Dubai means India doesn’t have to adjust to different pitches, making planning and execution easier.

 Reduced Travel Fatigue: While other teams move between cities and countries, India can stay in one place, minimizing fatigue.

 Better Game Strategy: Knowing the pitch well helps in team selection, batting approach, and bowling variations.

Counterarguments:

 Pressure of Expectations: Playing in a single venue puts India under immense scrutiny and expectations to win every game.

Opposition Gets Used to Conditions Too: Since every team plays at least one match in Dubai, they also get an opportunity to adapt.

Not India’s Decision: The decision was made by the ICC and BCCI based on political and security concerns, not by the Indian team.

Pakistan’s Struggles and Potential Exit from the Tournament

While India is thriving, Pakistan finds itself in deep trouble, sitting at the bottom of Group A with two consecutive losses. Their qualification for the semi-finals now depends on other results and a miracle performance in their last group match.

Even Pakistan captain Mohammad Rizwan admitted the situation looks bleak:

“Our campaign is as good as over.”

The criticism regarding India’s scheduling in Dubai might also stem from Pakistan’s struggles in the tournament, making it a talking point for fans and analysts alike.

What’s Next for India?

With a semi-final spot almost secured, India will look to continue their winning streak and capitalize on the momentum. The question remains—will the “Dubai advantage” controversy impact how India is perceived if they go on to win the tournament?

Stay updated with all the cricketing action, follow Cricadium on WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter, Telegram,  and Instagram